Case study: Retired Client looking For Advise

She approached me with an interesting question

should I pay for the house all cash or should get a mortgage since I making a nice profit of the house I am selling?

Now this is a Question we right away jump and say No don't pay for the house entirely all cash Just get a mortgage. after all this is what we sell our livelihood we are mortgage brokers our name will predict our answer!

But what is the right advise to the client?

What I answered to the client after taking every detail of her income and assets was, that  being that thats all the money she has, she should not dump all of it into the house. It will be very easy to put it all in there, but not as easy to retrieve it since she is retired. Now of course a reverse mortgage is always an option but how much she can take out will be determined based on life expectancy, and will not be a fast process!

Therefore I suggested to speak with a financial planner and to determine how much income she can realistically generate with the cash she has on hand, and based on that to determine how much of a conventional mortgage can she support with her total income.

What we will have accomplished

1) We have access to the money and principle at all times.

2) if the house goes down in value she still has her capital

3) We just reduced her tax liability on her total income since she has mortgage interest to deduct.

Sincerely

Joel Silberstein

PS. Of course there are other ways but I just wanted to point out this strategy

Comments

Just like to add that with interest rates still relatively low, she can probable find places to invest the money and still get a return after deducting the interest she pays in her mortgage. I wish I had her problem.
Posted by Roy Kotz (NPDodge) over 2 years ago
Always use OPM - I think everyone should live that way.
Posted by Simon Conway (Orlando Area Real Estate Services) over 2 years ago
You gave her sound advice Joel.  We're not financial advisors even though we have an impact on the financial bottom line.
Posted by Larry Wright (nwRealty.Com) over 2 years ago
This is a great post and great response! I am proud of you Joel!
Posted by Tim Davis (Titan Home Loans) over 2 years ago

Joel,

I don't know Tim Davis, but I agree with him.

Brian Brady wrote a great blog on this subject see: REALTORS: Pay Cash & Refinance Later? The IRS is Gonna Get You!

I took a different rout closer to your's, see: Risking Everything / Sharing The Risk

You've already warned her about it being hard and expensive to get the equity out if necessary. A retiree should protect her liquidity.

Bill

William J Archambault Jr

The Real Estate Investment Institute

First National Mortgage Sources

Posted by William J Archambault Jr (The Real Estate Investment Institute ) over 2 years ago

Participate



(optional)
What does the graphic say?